Bangkok--May 2--U.S. Information Service
The Clinton administration says it will file trade complaints in the World Trade Organization (WTO) against four countries for violating global trade rules on intellectual property protection.
U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky announced April 30 that she will initiate WTO dispute-settlement actions against Denmark, Sweden, Ireland and Ecuador, and that actions against Greece and Luxembourg may be initiated soon if these countries fail to meet their international obligations under the WTO Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of IntellectualProperty Rights (TRIPs).
The announcement coincided with publication of the administration's annual review of global intellectual property rights protection under the "Special 301" provisions of U.S. trade law. The two- month review examined the intellectual property policies and enfourcement provisions of some 70 countries.
Special 301, an amendment to U.S. trade law enacted in 1988, allows USTR to use Section 301 trade law to negotiate protection of intellectual property rights and to impose retaliatory trade sanctions should those negotiations fail to resolve the dispute.
In the USTR's annual review, countries engaging in the most onerous practices having the greatest adverse impact on U.S. exports are designated as "priority foreign countries" and are subject to Section 301 investigations. Other countries with less immediate and less egregious problems of protection or enforcement of intellectual property rights are placed on a "priority watch list" or a "watch list" and monitored closely for progress.
This year no economies are listed as "priority," while those on the "priority watch list" are: Argentina, Ecuador, Egypt, the European Union, Greece, India, Indonesia, Paraguay, Russia and Turkey. In addition, 36 trading partners are on the "watch list."
One of the ways Special 301 has been most effective in improving foreign protection of intellectual property is in its threat of retaliatory action, one senior U.S. trade official told reporters after release of the report.
The report noted progress in Bolivia, Brazil, Bulgaria, China, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Pakistan, the Philippines, Portugal, Russia, Taiwan, Turkey and Vietnam--most of which were previously listed under Special 301.
China is being handled differently from other countries because of the "serious and ongoing nature of substantial IPR piracy, "the report said. While noting that China has shut down 39 factories and other facilities producing pirated cassette disks, CD-ROMS and VDCs since September 1996, China will be designated for monitoring under Section 306 of the Trade Act of 1974. Section 306 allows USTR to monitor compliance with a bilateral trade agreement and to take immediate action, if neccessary, without Initiating a new investigation as prescribed under Section 301 law.
"We are not threatening to impose sanctions at this time," the senior trade official said. "They have done a pretty good job."
The United States expressed particular concern about copyright legislation passed by the Canadian government just prior to issuance of the Special 301 report. USTR will begin an immediate review of the legislation and if it is determined that there is a violation of IPR, the United States will take an action either under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) or the WTO, the senior official said.
He also said that a number of countries were cited under provisions of the TRIPs agreement, which entered into force this year for developed countries. The provisions won't apply to developing countries until January 2000.
"The TRIPs agreement has raised the bar a bit, and we are holding countries to the commitments of the TRIPs agreement," the senior official said.
For example, Denmark and Sweden were cited because the TRIPs agreement requires a country to allow surprise searches and seizures in cases of civil litigation. Where a large company buys a single piece of software and then copies it on all its machines, the holder of the copyright needs to be able to have law enforcement search and seize computers as evidence, the official explained. Because Denmark and Sweden don't provide for that protection, they were cited in the report.
Having acceded to the WTO late, Ecuador does not receive preferential WTO treatment for developing countries; USTR thus treated Ecuador like a developed country, subject to more-stringent WTO rules, in challenging widespread problems in protecting patents, copyrights and trademarks.
Ireland was cited because it has not yet amended its copyright law to comply with TRIPS obligations. The country has weaknesses in its protection of sound recordings and maintains very low criminal penalties that fail to deter piracy, USTR said.
USTR said that it will request dispute-settlement consultations with Greece by July 1 unless that government takes action to stop Greek television stations from broadcasting U.S.-owned movies without authorization or payment of required compensation. And USTR will initiate WTO proceedings against Luxembourg by September 1997 if the country doesn't amend its copyright law to provide better protection of sound recordings.
Of the six intellectual property actions taken by the United States over the last year, three have yielded positive results: Japan has improved its protection of sound recordings, Pakistan has changed its process of pharmaceutical patents, and Portugal has passed amendments to its patent law, the U.S. official said.
In the other cases, the United States is proceeding with a WTO case against India over pharmaceutical patents and is pursuing consultations with Thailand over trademarks and with Turkey over discriminatory taxes on foreignmovies.
Following is the Thailand portion of the report:
Thailand: Although Thailand is poised to strengthen its intellectual property protection by launching an intellectual property and international trade court and by enacting a TRIPS-consistent patent law, the United States is seriously concerned about the continued decline in enforcement activity. Since the end of enforcement campaigns in 1993-1994, the numbers of arrests and seizures of illicit goods has plummeted. To date, no pirate nor counterfeiter has served time in prison for copying or selling protected goods, and fines and sentences remain too law to deter offenders. Thailand is still in the process of amending its patent law to comply with the TRIPS Agreement. We will again review Thailand's intellectual property protection efforts in an out-of-cycle review to be conducted in the fall of 1997.
For the full USTR report on Special 301 Annual Review, please visit the USIS home page at: http://www.inet.co.th/org/usis. End.