Bangkok--Feb 16--UNISBKK.
The heads of the five United Nations regional Commissions scribed the impact of globalization in their areas of the world, as part of an interactive dialogue held at the start of this afternoon's meeting of the Tenth United Nations Conference Trade and Development (UNCTAD X), now meeting in Bangkok.
The result of globalization in Africa had either been minimal or negative, and the phenomenal increases in global trade had largely bypassed the continent, K.Y. Amoako, the Executive Secretary of the Economic Commission for Africa, told the Conference. Globalization has widened existing inequalities and marginalized developing countries, and the current international system has placed obstacles in their way. Action had to be taken at global, regional and national levels.
Adrianus Mooy, Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, said globalization's impact on his region was varied. However, he observed, those States that were fully integrated in the world economy had experienced high growth, but had also suffered most from the recent financial crisis. Those States that were less well integrated had experienced slower growth, but also less damage. The question, he said, was to find the mid-course.
Latin America and the Caribbean had experienced high rates of growth in trade, but much smaller improvements in gross domestic product, Jose A. Ocampo, Executive Secretary of the region's Economic Commission, explained. High levels of regional integration and free trade and preferential agreements with developed States were important features of the economic landscape of South and Central America.
Europe was experiencing regionalization, rather than globalization of trade and capital movements, Yves Berthelot, Executive Secretary of the Economic Commission for Europe, told the round-table discussion. Trade in both the export and import sectors was more and more focused on Europe.
Hazem El-Beblawi, Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia, explained that the Middle East was a geographical, political and cultural notion, but hardly an economic reality. The region seemed to be integrated into the global economy, but this was a distortion derived from oil exports and a high imported food bill. There was very little intra-regional investment, but the States of the region invested between $400 and $600 billion outside the area.
In the Conference's resumed general debate, Ana Maria Solares Gaiti, Vice Minister for Economic Relations of Bolivia, explained that just as economies had been globalized, so too had economic crises. The international community must be capable of globalizing solutions. In order to do that, it needed a vision of development that allowed competitiveness and efficiency to be combined with delivery of social needs. Action was needed to guide globalization, she said, and no delay could be brooked.
Kingsley T. Wickramaratne, Minister of Internal and International Commerce and Food of Sri Lanka, said globalization was an irreversible process. However globalization was not a sufficient condition for development, as many factors inhibited developing countries' participation in the international trading system. In order to benefit from the new opportunities, developing countries needed market access, human and financial resources, technology and adequate infrastructure. Less advanced and vulnerable small and commodity-dependent countries did not have suchre quirements.
Also in the general debate, the Conference heard statements by the Second Deputy Prime Minister of Uganda; the Deputy Prime Minister of Mauritius; Iraq's Minister of Trade; the Deputy Prime Minister of Romania; Bhutan's Minister of Trade and Industry; the Minister of Trade of the Russian Federation; the Minister of Commerce of Nigeria; Nepal's Minister of Commerce; the Minister of Commerce of Algeria; the State Secretary of the Ministry of Economy of Slovakia; the Vice Minister of Commerce and Tourism of the Lao People's Democratic Republic; and the Minister of Development of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia..
The Conference will meet again at 9 a.m. tomorrow, 15 February, to hear a keynote address from Juan Somavia, Director-General of the International Labour Organisation, as part of its programme of interactive dialogues. It will then resume its general debate.
Interactive Discussion
YVES BERTHELOT, Executive Secretary of the Economic Commission for Europe (ECE): Globalization is either viewed as a trend or as the political programme of a group of countries, such as the Group of Seven Industrialized Countries. In Europe, we observe a regionalization and not a globalization, both for trade and movements of capital. Trade in both the export and import sectors is more and more focused on Europe. Within the region and the outlying associated countries, only the Russian Federation has not changed the international structure of its trade.
Trade is basically intra-industrial, and enterprises trying to import want to minimize risks that they take. In doing this, they have a tendency to reduce the economic and geographic distance between them and their partners. This generally tends to leave them with countries that are as developed as they are and not far away. Capital movements are also basically concentrated in Europe. The conclusion to be drawn is that while much is said about global governance, it is important to consider regional governance.
The political programme in the region is based on neo-classical neo-liberal economic policies developed in the spirit of globalization. The basic problem is the location of sources. Therefore, the belief that location is optimal automatically because of liberalization and privatization is a false one. Without institutions, one cannot manage a market economy. Also, short-term capital movements are very volatile. As a result, European governments are cautious, and sometimes too cautious. Interest rates are therefore too high in countries with economies in transition. This has hampered the initiative of enterprises because they are uncertain about the demands that they will face.
ADRIANUS MOOY, Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP): There is wide variety of impacts of globalization in the Asia and Pacific region, but there is a strong correlation between integration and the influence of globalization. East Asia is fully integrated. South-East Asia, at least before the crisis, is well integrated. These countries have high growth rates and good economic performances, but they also bore the brunt of the crisis. South Asia is slowly integrating, and the other States are basically not integrated. South Asia's performance has been moderate and the others stable, but the countries of these areas were not much affected by the crisis. Integrating fast seems to mean big benefits but also prospects for trouble. Slower integration leads to slower growth, but less risk. The question is, of course, how to find the mid-course.
In Asia and the Pacific, the volume of trade is not merely effected by the region and by policies but also by the pattern of investment. So far the impact of the Uruguay round and the World Trade Organization (WTO) is limited in the ESCAP region, because only 24 States are members of WTO -less than half those are members of ESCAP. In addition, the products of great interest to countries of the region are still outside the trade regime -- mainly agriculture and textiles.
Foreign direct investment to the region has increased but the source and type of industry influence the effect the investment has on the volume of trade. Investment from Japan and the newly industrialized States goes mainly to labour-intensive industries. These are export industries in the home country, and contribute little to the volume of intra-regional trade. If Japan and developed countries of the region could absorb more of these goods, then obviously intra-regional trade would increase. Investment from North America and Europe is mostly in natural resources, or in manufacturing components for assembling elsewhere. Thus its impact on intra-regional trade is also limited.
JOSE A. OCAMPO, Executive Secretary of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC): Latin America and the Caribbean have employed two strategies -- opening up markets and strengthening regional ties. Renewal and creation of regional integration agreements and very active free trade agreements can be seen in the region. Mexico has it free trade agreement with the United States and the Central American, Caribbean and Andean States receive a large number of preferences granted by the United States.
Diversification is dynamic in Mexico as a result of its trading with the United States. There is very lively trading within the continent, with a large piece coming from manufactures. These are almost over-represented. We have also seen interesting diversification in the Caribbean and Central American economies, and marked increases in trade with the United States. Imports have also increased, so there are trade imbalances and deficits in some cases. The 9 per cent growth caused a much smaller increase in gross domestic product (GDP).
There has been spectacular foreign direct investment to the region, so that now some $80-90 billion comes into the region. This has had the effect of concentrating production in foreign hands. After the privatization period, there were many takeovers of newly-private companies by large multinationals. There has also been foreign direct investment within the region -- about 3 to 5 per cent of all foreign direct investment. There have been two major crises; the 1994-1995 Tequila crisis and the recent international financial crisis. These have a bearing on the rhythm of regional growth.
KINGSLEY Y. AMOAKO, Executive Secretary of the Economic Commission for Africa (ECA): Globalization needs to be looked at in terms of the major challenge facing Africa -- poverty reduction and eradication. Since the mid-1990s there has been some growth on the continent. However, to reduce poverty by the year 2015 to the level advocated by the international community, African GDP must grow by 7 per cent per annum. Sustainable development, human capital development, structural diversification of economies, and macro-economic stability are some of the key factors that will push African countries towards economic stability.
Globalization should be seen as the mutual flow of goods and services that will contribute to dramatic change. However, in Africa, the impact of the process has either been minimal or negative and the phenomenal increases in global trade have largely bypassed the continent. Africa's share of global exports and trade has also declined because the industrialized countries have protected themselves from the continent's dynamic exports.
The ratio of foreign direct investment to gross domestic product has declined by half in the African countries. The flows coming in are concentrated in few countries such as Nigeria, Egypt and Morocco. The flows are also not going to sectors with the greatest opportunity for technological transfer. Fifty per cent is going to countries with oil and related industries and the rest to States with mining industries.
Globalization has widened existing inequalities and marginalized developing countries. The current international system has also placed obstacles in the way of these countries. In addition, inadequate policies are being applied. The issue is basically one of measures to be taken to address the problems. Action has to be taken at three levels: global, regional and national. Africa is losing its shares in its traditional exports and intra-regional trade and cooperation are not increasing.
HAZEM EL-BEBLAWI, Executive Secretary of the Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA): Is the Middle East a region strictly speaking and to what extent is it integrated in the world? There is also very little economic integration in the region. The Middle East is a geographical, political and cultural notion but hardly an economic reality. Intra-regional trade is about 10 per cent. The region is, however, a major exporter of oil. Trade in oil can give a distorted image about intra-regional trade. If oil, which goes mainly to the West, is taken away from the equation, intra-regional trade then accounts for about 30 per cent.
It looks apparently as though the region is integrated in the global economy. But again, that is based on the oil exports and a high imported food bill. In terms of investments within the region, there is very little foreign direct investment. It amounts to 10 per cent of what is being received by developing countries and 1 per cent of GDP. However, the region as a whole is investing $400 to $600 billion outside.
The impact of the financial crisis is also minimal. Not because of the strengths of the region, but merely because the region is marginally integrated in the financial capital markets. Indirectly it was affected by the decline in commodity prices until that was adjusted a few months ago. It was also affected by the depreciation of foreign exchange.
In response to what is being done to improve regional trade, we are working to enhance economic cooperation. There are various schemes, such as a free-trade zone, among others. One member of the region also has a special agreement with Europe.
As to whether regionalism is the building block for globalization, it will help to bring countries together. However, the degree of industrialization is not high enough.
Mr. AMOAKO said that regional integration is strong. The ECA works in concert with the Organization of Africa Unity (OAU) and the African Development Bank, and has a joint secretariat to help push regional integration. We have been doing a lot for regional integration, but the challenge is huge. There are problems related to integration in areas where there in one dominant State.
We have been strengthening regional institutions by providing technical assistance to sub-regional organizations, and working with African States to facilitate their integration into the WTO process. Next year we will issue an annual report on the status of regional integration, for which we have developed benchmarks. We will also examine the consistency of national programmes for integration and examine how policies can contribute. Infrastructure development in Africa is critical. The greatest trade barrier in Africa is transport costs. For many years the ECA has been working with bilateral partners and the United Nations to integrate transport. Recently we hosted a meeting of civil aviation ministers, out of which a declaration to liberalize air space was elaborated. Information technology is also critical and we are working with 20 African countries to develop strategies to improve use of information technologies.
Mr. OCAMPO said that ECLAC had played a key role in American integration, and has given rise to a number of agreements. For some time now, regional integration has taken on a life of its own.
The fundamental task of ECLAC is analytical, and it defends some if its ideas on integration in its latest annual report. We argue that open regionalism is not incompatible with globalization but rather is a vital support to it. Globalization has to be complimentary to strong national and regional institutions.
In the trade sector, where diverse flows of trade exist, integration is a useful tool for development. Regional flows also bring small to mediumsized businesses into the world trade. Great importance is attached to financial cooperation at regional levels, including macro-economic integration tools like the reserve fund, and the expansion of the Development Bank. For small countries, the best defence in an unstable financial world is the possibility of various financing mechanisms, for both balance of payments and for development.
Mr. MOOY: A number of regional trading arrangements are based on a product-by-product basis. Others are still at the initial stage. The Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) is also being assisted in trade facilitation. ESCAP is collaborating in special programme for the economies of Asia as well. The Commission is also promoting intra-regional cooperation
Mr. BERTHELOT: We are trying to help the various countries in Europe and the economies in transition to integrate into the world at large. However, every system can only be stable if certain conditions are met: the legitimate authority of those in charge; and the generation of growth that is evenly distributed. One of the main thrusts is assisting economies in transition by focusing on the development of institutions, including market institutions, and recommending macro-economic policies.
The European Union is an important reference point for countries in transition, since the Union protects its members. There are various ways of organizing a market economy and not just one way. There is a need to create instruments that will maintain Europe's cohesion and give members the concept of ownership.
In discussing whether politics or economics provided the major impetus, Mr. EL-BEBLAWI explained that while regional integration is a public good, the criterion employed by decision makers is not the total benefit to everyone, but rather the accrued benefit to them. In many cases, integration does not benefit these leaders. Democracy is probably a precondition to economic integration. In the Western Asian region, leaders are more concerned with political security than with general economic benefit.
Mr. AMOAKO said that in Africa the political rationale and impetus for regional integration is strong, and has been from independence. For African leaders it has become even more important with globalization and marginalization. Africa is the most subdivided continent, with 53 countries. Economic integration will give a more powerful voice to Africa, both politically and economically.
Mr. MOOY said it is hard to separate the political from the economic; however the Asia-Pacific region had seen regional organizations established for reasons that were primarily political and primarily economic. The ASEAN was started for political reasons, but in 1975 its first summit in Bali spoke of economic matters.
In Western Europe, Mr. BERTHELOT said, the cold war and also the Marshall Plan, which included an obligation on recipient States that they coordinate with their neighbours, helped motivation for regional integration. This became the embryonic negotiating basis for the region. Europe as an integrated entity began slowly with a series of technical matters. Only a great deal later did political motivations arise.
Speaking about systems of regional trade preferences, Mr. AMOAKO said there can be no development without industrialization, and for Africa, economic integration will provide the next step towards development. Africa was the only part of the world that will be forced to industrialize without the preferences others had received in the past. Markets are imperfect, so some form of government intervention will be required.
On the same subject, Mr. OCAMPO said that for Latin America and the Caribbean, preferences would be an important factor in development for the smallest States. They were very dependent on preferences from the United States, Canada and Europe. Unilateral reductions of trade barriers affect everyone. It was important, in speaking of open trade, to realize that tariffs are not the only barriers to trade. Many other barriers apply, particularly regionally. Language barriers could impede trade, for Example. More importantly, integration will have to be more consolidated in order to fit the international trends. What is termed "deep integration" will not merely include trade integration but also integration on social and environmental issues.
It was also noted that there was a great deal of captive trade among neighboring countries because of transport costs.
Statements Made in General Debate
MOSES ALI, Minister of Tourism, Trade and Industry of Uganda: Least developed countries (LDCs) recognized their primary responsibility for their own development and have therefore undertaken major reforms of their economies and improved macro-economic management. But for these reforms to succeed, a supporting international environment is essential. A major obstacle to Africa's economic development is the lack of sufficient development finance to invest in human resources development and physical infrastructure, which are essential for sustained development and growth. ODA has fallen to historically low levels precisely at a time when it is most needed and when policy reforms are rendering aid more effective.Greater support for infrastructure development, including road and rail networks, telecommunications capacities, computer systems and port facilities, would leave a tangible mark while generating employment, expertise and revenues. In addition, investment in human resources must be recognized as a driving force for development and long-term competitiveness.
External debt relief and the transfer of new resources, as well as continued domestic policy efforts, are the key to sustained recovery. Technical assistance, as originally envisaged, was designed to close the gap between the industrial and developing countries by accelerating the transfer of knowledge, skills and expertise, thereby building national capacity. It is unfortunate that after four decades of technical assistance, most of the funds earmarked for this purpose are still spent on foreign expertise, even when and where national experts are available.
Concrete measures are required to enhance the capacity of developing countries to participate in and benefit from the global trading system. Development partners should provide bound duty-free and quota-free market access for products originating from LDCs.
RAKASWUR PURRYAG, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign Affairs and International Trade of Mauritius: The view is sometimes expressed that e-commerce may solve the problems of small island developing States. While it may mitigate the problem of isolation and contribute to the development of service industries, it is not a panacea for solving their development problems. Issues relating to the production of goods and their actual transportation will remain. The problems of small island developing States arise essentially from their specificities. The absence of economies of scale due to the small size of their internal markets results in high unit costs of utilities and transactional costs, including high freight costs, which affect the competitiveness of their export products. These States are also exposed to the trade and income volatility that creates vulnerability.
The provisions of special and differential treatment for developing countries may not be adequate and suitable to meet the exigencies of globalization. Rather, a new dimension on vulnerability affecting the sustainable development of small island developing States should be built into the basic rules of the WTO and its sectoral agreements so as to create a level playing field. Island States should be assisted in their gradual integration into the world economy by continuing to provide them with trade preferences that will help to mitigate some of their constraints and make their products competitive.
The World Bank and UNCTAD have done some very useful work on the problems facing small island developing States, especially in the construction of a generally acceptable index to address their development needs. UNCTAD should expedite its work in this area and develop a suitable index, in collaboration with other institutions, to gauge the developmental needs of island States.
(More)