Globalisation Tests the Region's Governments as They Strive to Attain Social Progress

ข่าวทั่วไป Friday November 14, 1997 10:19 —PRESS RELEASE LOCAL

Bangkok--November 14--UNIS
Can Open Economies Fill the Needs of the Neediest?
The Asia and Pacific region presents a puzzling and frustrating paradox. Despite decades of world-beating economic expansion, it remains home to the vast majority of the world's poor. Its new-found prosperity, evidenced by the traffic jams of shiny cars that snarl the region's capitals, or the crisp new buildings that populate their skylines, appears to have been lost on its millions of destitute and downtrodden. From 1987 to 1993, a period when most Asian and Pacific economies were experiencing a boom unparalleled in their post-war history, the number of people living in absolute poverty in the region rose from 960 million to 1.3 billion, an increase of 35 per cent. No one who lives in the region, or visits it, can avoid witnessing its astounding extremes of poverty and wealth: the rickshaw sharing the road with the limousine, the shantytown in the shadow of the skyscraper, or the malnourished child beside emerald fields of rice.
The evidence is clear: as countries have grown richer, their population as a whole have not automatically become better off in terms of accepted social progress criteria. The theory that the benefits of growth would sooner or later trickle down to the poor has not worked very well, or very widely, says Edward Van Roy, director of the social development arm of the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP). Except where specific polices or programmes are in place to assist the poor, the unemployed and the disenfranchised, wealth generally goes to those who already have prospered. In its 53rd session report, the Bangkok-based United Nations organisation observed that although growth in a number of Asian and Pacific countries and areas had indeed reduced the percentage of the poor in their populations, it had, in many cases, actually heightened social and economic inequalities. For example, in Thailand in 1992, the richest 10 per cent of the people received over one-third their nation's income -- while the poorest 20 per cent subsisted on slightly over 5 per cent. That case is hardly unique; indeed, the majority of countries and areas in the ESCAP region suffer from similar imbalances. Based on the data, it appears that South-East Asian countries such as Malaysia, Thailand and the Philippines had even greater income inequalities than Bangladesh, Nepal, Sri Lanka or China.
The challenge of ensuring that growth does fill the needs of the neediest is the reason why over 120 senior officials from 28 nations throughout the Asia and Pacific region gathered in Manila in early November, at the invitation of ESCAP and the Philippine government. The Fifth Asian and Pacific Ministerial Conference on Social Development had an overarching task: to advance specific policies to help eliminate poverty, reduce unemployment and promote social justice in the region. It is, to say the least, a massive endeavour solving poverty is a multifarious project, which requires attention not only to the economic but the social, political and environmental causes of poverty.
The job is made even more daunting by recent economic shocks in the region that have clearly unsettled governments. It is one of our era's greatest ironies that, even as we have achieved more in the past 50 years than in the past 50 decades, we find people across the globe more anxious for their lives, their jobs, their freedom, their security, said Ernesto Garilao, the Philippines Agrarian Reform Secretary, as he opened the four-day meeting of senior officials, the first segment of the week-long conference.
The meeting's task is eased by an existing region-wide consensus, hammered out three years ago in the same city by another gathering of Asian and Pacific ministers and senior officials. At that 1994 meeting, the regionฆs governments agreed on a number of specific targets in social development -- in fields as varied as environment and housing, employment and health -- that they pledged to achieve in the coming decades. These targets include, among others, the elimination of absolute poverty by 2010, the halving of infant mortality rates by 2000 and the provision of energy and waste disposal facilities to all settlements in Asia and the Pacific by 2025. The goals, enshrined in a document called the Agenda for Action for Social Development in the ESCAP Region, were later presented, in March 1995, to world leaders at the World Summit on Social Development in Copenhagen, Denmark.
This year's Fifth Asian and Pacific Ministerial Conference is intended to evaluate action taken on the promises made by ESCAP member nations since then and to see if those goals can be met faster. There has, indeed, been progress on a number of fronts. Not the least is the now nearly universal acceptance of the idea that constructing open, liberalised and globally competitive economies is the key to maintaining economic growth, without which social advancement is impossible. Few countries in the region would disagree: attracting foreign capital is far preferred to asking for handouts. According to Kazi Jalal, the representative of the Manila-based Asian Development Bank to the conference, the flow of private-sector financing to developing countries in 1997 is estimated to be five times the amount of official development aid.
Yet the recent collapse of Southeast Asian currencies and its reverberations around the region have taken many governments aback. Leaders now worry not only about the political consequences of globalisation but also about the challenges posed to national efforts to promote social development by such far-reaching and at times unpredictable -- financial flows. Surapong Posayanond, head of the Thai delegation, said as much when he told the conference that Many factors in the process of globalisation are beyond the control of individual developing countries. This vulnerability to global forces compounds the difficulties faced by governments in restructuring their economies Already, the reduction of state spending and employment and the closure or streamlining of state-owned enterprises has put thousands out of work. The lowering of tariffs has also forced formerly protected industries to shed jobs. Since 1990, for example, economic reforms have actually raised poverty in India. The situation is even more acute in the so-called transitional economies of Central Asia, where employment has contracted in recent years.
The costs of globalisation are almost too numerous to count. The temptation for large-scale borrowing, the tendency for high inflation and the acceptance of environmental degradation are only a few of the unforeseen and unplanned results of more open economies, which are now being felt in some Asian-Pacific developing countries with a vengeance. The new ease in travel, while liberating, has also increased the spread of diseases. Of the 3.1 million new HIV infections in 1996, 1.5 million were in Asia. And booming cities are drawing in the poor in droves, attracted by the hope of better employment. Although rural poor have historically been the most numerous as a percentage of the total number of poor people in the Asian and Pacific region, the number of urban poor has been leaping upwards, as in Bangladesh between 1974 and 1991, and in the Philippines between 1971 and 1991.
In the long-run, globalisation promises more prosperity. But in the short-term, it not only complicates efforts to alleviate poverty, but also puts job security in a precarious position. ESCAP has noted the increase in contract labour and temporary employmen in recent times. Businesses prefer the flexibility, higher productivity and lower costs afforded by contract labour, even though workers sometimes lose out on benefits and protection. Given the problems posed by a shifting workforce, there might be a temptation for countries to think of ways to keep those who are already employed on payrolls as long as possible. But, as Amarjit Singh Oberai, the International Labour Organisation's (ILO) South Asia advisory team director, told the conference The important thing is not job security but income and employment security. In other words, governments should focus on creating the conditions so that anyone who wants a job can find one.
The opening of markets is also causing a host of social challenges that supersede borders, not the least of which is that of protecting migrant labour. The issue took a prominent place at the conference. Many nations, including Indonesia and the Philippines, strongly urged the delegates to smooth labour flows and eliminate the often tragic consequences of illegal migration. Employment under an era of integrated economies will mean internationally shared human resources, reads the Philippine statement to the conference. Internationally-shared resources must, likewise, be internationally-cared for. Nonetheless, countries which are destinations for migrant workers fear the added burden these new arrivals place on their social systems. Malaysia noted that it already employs 1.7 million foreign workers.
Protecting and developing labour, just as in solving poverty, is a many-levelled process. Sri Lanka, among other Asia-Pacific developing countries, is considering new programmes to support the families of female migrant workers. The World Health Organisation representative, B.P. Kean, reminded the conference that providing basic health services should not be ignored in the drive to expand employment and reduce poverty. If employment opportunities are provided, yet those in poverty are not fit to work,ฆ he said, ฆwe achieve little. Labour development also requires attention to future human resources, for only by ensuring that children are well-nourished and well-educated can governments expect future workers to be up to their full physical and mental potential. Once again, the task ahead is enormous: Some 73 million people in India, 28 million both in Pakistan and in China, and 20 million in Bangladesh have had no schooling whatsoever.
If there was one lesson delegates could take back from the conference, it is that despite the worrying challenges posed by globalisation, and the bewildering variety of tasks needed to promote social development, governments have shown that they are coping, and some with distinction. China, home to a fifth of the worldฆs population, presented a series of signal successes. Despite adding millions every year to its labour pool (between 1993 and 1994, 9 million Chinese joined the workforce), China has been able to control unemployment. In 1996, urban unemployment hovered around 3 per cent. By the end of the century, Beijing expects to have solved the food and clothing shortages of some 80 million people in poor rural areas. Due to an increased stress on child immunisation, the occurrence rate of four major infectious childhood diseases had dropped by 90 per cent.
China is, of course, not the only nation with impressive achievements to report. In 1996, Viet Nam set up a bank to help the poor develop businesses, as well as started providing poor households with access to vocational training. From 25 per cent in 1994, the percentage of poor households has fallen to 19.2 per cent in 1997. Sprawling Indonesia expects to eradicate absolute poverty by 2004, six years earlier than the date set by the Regional Social Development Agenda. Malaysia, for its part, believes it can meet that goal by 2000 -- a reasonable claim, given its laudable progress since 1970. The percentage of households living below the poverty line in Malaysia has dropped since that year from 52.4 per cent to 9.6 per cent in 1995. Meanwhile, the Maldives, a nation of islands in the Indian Ocean, reports that absolute poverty there no longer exists. And in Brunei Darussalam, where poverty is unheard of and health care is free, the government has achieved nine out of the ten WHO indicators signifying Health for All.
Nonetheless, many expressed concern that their efforts have not gone far enough, or have been stymied by their limitations. Despite 40 years of planned development efforts, the country has remained poor, said the head of the Nepalese delegation, Punya Prasad Dahal, who was also elected vice-chairman of the conference. In the landlocked Himalayan kingdom, he reported, 45 per cent of the people live below the poverty line. The representative from Laos, Senghanh Soukhaseum, pointed out the difficulties inherent in trying to advance the society of a country that has had 3 million tons of munitions dropped on it in the Viet Nam conflict in the 1970s. Meanwhile, Sri Lankaฆs delegate, V. Jegarasasingam, expressed alarm at the high rate of suicides in her country -- 26 a day, by one count. Even in the tiny Maldives, challenges remain, such as malnutrition and the discrepancy between rural and urban incomes. Delivering resources to islands is like putting money in the ocean, said the countryฆs representative, Asim Ahmed. You have to put in a lot to get back a little.
In their Message to Manila, 107 representatives of non-government organisations from 27 countries and territories in the Asia-Pacific region recognised that while there have been some important achievements, it is clear that greater political will on the part of all, especially by governments, is required to meet the challenge set...in the Regional Agenda. They urged the assembled governments to pay special attention, in the next few years, to halving malnutrition and illiteracy rates, providing all people with access to safe drinking water and eradicating absolute poverty.
The representative from the Netherlands was one of a number of delegates who urged the conference to pay more attention to gender issues. Women still comprise the region's largest and most pervasive excluded group. In some countries, such as India and Pakistan, the number of years of schooling for women is barely one-third that of men. And even in countries where the participation of women in the labour force is high, women are rarely found in the ranks of administration or management. Although as clerical workers, women's numbers often exceed that of men, as in Mongolia, the Philippines and Thailand. The glass ceiling in the way of women's advancement remains.
It is too early to tell what further impact globalisation will have on Asian and Pacific governmentsฆ efforts to end poverty, unemployment and discrimination. Although more and more governments are putting increasing funds aside for social development Indonesia, for example, now spends almost 38% per cent of its budget on social programs the uncertainty that hangs over many economies casts a long shadow. Unfortunately, ฆtrickle- downฆ does work when there is a downturn, says ESCAP's Social Development Director Van Roy. A slowing in investment and business in short, a contraction of wealth -- translates quite easily into more unemployment and more poverty.
Before the economic turmoil, the World Bank had estimated that the percentage of the poor in the region would drop to 4 per cent in East Asia and 26 per cent in South Asia by 2000. When Asian and Pacific ministers and senior officials meet again, in 1999, to evaluate their progress towards meeting the goals of the Regional Social Development Agenda, their ability to adjust to the region and the world's new economic realities will determine if that prediction will exceed, or fall short of, reality. As the past few years have already shown, wealth needs to be used well, if prosperity is ever to beget a better life for all in the region.--End

แท็ก World Bank   Indonesia   pakistan   thailand   Beijing   central  

เว็บไซต์นี้มีการใช้งานคุกกี้ ศึกษารายละเอียดเพิ่มเติมได้ที่ นโยบายความเป็นส่วนตัว และ ข้อตกลงการใช้บริการ รับทราบ