Bangkok--November 19--Burson Marsteller
Despite the attention to stock market movements in the region, a look at the capital structure of most Asian companies show that they have actually been more adept in the regional debt markets. They are renown for their ability to play off bankers one against the other. But with the financial turmoil in the region’s markets since mid-summer, it seems clear that managements are going to have to learn to be just as effective in the equity markets if their companies are to survive in the new capital-raising environment wrought by recent economic events.
For the short-term, its likely that the debt markets will be all but closed to many Asian firms. Currencies have crashed, and the cost of surfacing US$-denominated debt has skyrocketed. No relief is available in local markets, as currency pressures have pushed up local borrowing rates and absorbed market liquidity. Rating agencies such as Moody’s & Standard & Poor’s, have downgraded sovereign debt in many countries, in effect downgrading corporate debt as well. And in Indonesia and Thailand, there are simply fewer local lenders to borrow from!
In combination, and perhaps except for the most well-capitalized and financially well-managed firms, the equity markets will take on new importance. Not just in terms of new issues, but in the management of current share price and related matters. In this new environment, competition for capital among local firms will be fierce. There will be greater scrutiny of offerings by investors, lower premiums on new shares, greater difficulty in attracting willing investors, and it is likely that those who do invest will invest proportionally less than in the past. The scoreboard itself may be changing. One institutional investor, speaking in Manila last week, said investor’s measure of Asian firms’ corporate performance in the future will not be earnings per share, but return on equity and dividend policy.
How prepared are companies in Asia to manage this transition? Probably not very well. Asian companies are experienced in tapping the equity markets, but largely for one-time, short-term gain. Once a share issue is done, the tendency is for most companies to all but forget the stock market and share price. Compared with their counterparts in the West, listed firms in Asia lag far behind when it comes to supporting share price. This is a skill which is going to have to be learned or imported.
In short, listed companies in Asia will be forced to become masters of investor relations if they intend to successfully tap funds from the global capital markets.
The overriding goal of investor relations is quite straightforward: it is to ensure the lowest cost of capital, and the highest sustainable price for a company’s shares. But there are accompanying benefits, including better liquidity for a company’s shares and a more diversified - as well as more loyal - investor base. As well, a strong share price is a powerful asset for any company in acquisition mode, and on the defensive side, good preventive medicine if a company itself is an acquisition target.
These goals and benefits cannot be obtained simply by waving a magic wand, nor without good and consistent operating performance. Good company fundamentals will matter more in this new environment, as investors turn away from “concept” stocks or “buying the market” to more careful consideration of a listed company’s own future prospects.
To be successful, companies will have to commit to more and better communication with investors and the market. More aggressive in courting investors. Comfortable with more open and timely disclosure, revealing not just more, but more meaningful information. And there will be a requirement for greater corporate transparency generally, and acceptance and adoption of financial practices more aligned to a “world standard” in reporting and financial communication. Stock exchanges and regulatory bodies in the region have been pressing for this, but listed firms have been slow to respond. The exigencies of the market may now be more successful than the stock exchanges or regulatory bodies have been in bringing about this change.
Communication? It is the essential ingredient, and what drives good investor relations. But it’s more than that.
One can persuasively argue that the existence of a global financial market is a myth, or at least premature. What we are living and investing in is a global information market in which words and thoughts and ideas - and yes, rumor and inside information - are the currencies of investment. It is information that moves markets. And not just market talk, the company’s financials, the information available on Bloomberg or Reuters or Dow Jones, or recommendations from security analysts.
Performance and financial data is important, but only one of the things that combine to create perceptions about the attractiveness of an individual stock. In fact, non-financial factors are said to drive 35% of investment decisions among buy-side analysts, according to a new study by accounting firm Ernst & Young. The study concluded that “non-financial criteria are fed by performance, and in turn, feed the perception of performance.”
So perceptions about a company’s strategy and direction, it’s future prospects and the quality and capability of its management do matter. These, and several others according to the Ernst & Young report, are all critical factors which significantly influence investment decisions. To what else can you attribute, for example, the fact that Microsoft, with US$11.3 billion in sales, has a market capitalization four times that of General Motors and greater than the market cap of the entire Thai stock market?
If information and investor perceptions are critical, it is time Asian companies begin thinking about communications and investor relations as a strategic tool they cannot do without, and need to apply consistently and relentlessly. Investor relations is probably the most important unmanaged function within 99.9% of the listed companies in the region, and as important a financial management tool as any they now employ. Given the stakes, investor relations is as important to manage as relationships with bankers or rating agencies. And far too important to put in the hands of a junior executive or secretary, which all too often is the case with the way companies in the region are managing this function today.
In present circumstances especially, companies must move to address this imbalance. And there are several things they can, ought and need to do.
For one, they must commit to paying greater attention to critical investment audiences -- shareholders and investors, and investment influencers such as security analysts and the financial news media. A good place to begin is with a re-thinking of corporate disclosure policy, more consistent and better prepared for contact with these important audiences, and the setting a goal of ‘no unpleasant surprises.’
It is important as well to begin planning now for reporting of 1997 results. Reporting on 1997 developments and performance will have to be different than in the past, as both expectations for disclosure and skepticism will be greater than before. More attention will be focus on what companies are saying, not just how they are saying it. And expecting the annual report alone to communicate all that needs to be communicated will probably not suffice.
Furthermore, companies will need to take fuller advantage of all the financial tools and techniques available to them. These include:
- Annual and interim reports which do more than simply report, but provide context to developments and analyze performance.
- Company financial fact books which provide even more detail to the numbers behind the numbers, and why.
- Routine, informational roadshows (in which the goal is quality , not quantity) aimed at analysts and investors, and unrelated to a planned offering or issue.
- An increased schedule of company visits by analysts and investors. These can be time-consuming, but they are imperative in building and maintaining a following. Companies need to be selective with whom they invest this much time, and such meetings must be carefully prepared for - each visit should have a goal behind it, and the company’s messages clearly defined in advance.
- Increased use of one-on-one meetings with key institutional investors, either in Asia or in their home markets. These interactions should be carefully targeted, with the aim to spend time with those whose investment goals and policies match the company’s. Such meetings present an opportunity for the company to do and present its own analysis of performance and prospects, rather than forcing investors to rely on analysis done by third-parties such as sell-side analysts.
- Consider quarterly or semi-annual conference calls with analysts, fund managers, other institutional investors to keep them apprised of developments, and to better manage their expectations.
- And overall, make it simple and convenient for securities analyst, fund managers, institutional investors and key financial journalists to get to comprehensive company data and corporate information. Today, this is a relative easy task, even across nine or ten time zones, with the technology to communicate via e-mail, and provide access to company background, reports, filings and news via Internet websites (as long as they can find you on the Internet!).
This new focus on the equity market is a newly more important playing field for listed firms in Asia. Not only is it more important, it will be more competitive than ever before. CEOs and CFOs will be asked more and more difficult questions than ever before. Expectations regarding disclosure and communication and the availability of corporate financial information will be greater than ever before.
But if experience is a guide, investors will find, follow and stay longer with those companies it’s made easiest to follow. Their perceptions need to be actively managed. And Asian companies need to get ready to play in this game.
Chuck Newton is Chairman of Burson-Marsteller’s Asia/Pacific Corporate Practice. This article is based on his remarks at The CFO Forum, held Nov. 7-9 in Manila.
For more information, contact:
Burson-Marsteller
Porntip Lertvechakul
Office Tel: 252-9871-7
email: [email protected].