Bangkok--Sep 21---Fitch-London/New York
Fitch-London/New York: 18 September 2001: Following last week's attacks in the US, Fitch is today issuing a comment on the implications for sovereign ratings. This release follows others issued yesterday and today by Fitch's banking, corporate and insurance teams in London, Chicago and New York.
Global economic outlook
Last week's events in the United States will have no immediate implications for Fitch's sovereign ratings. However, as will be discussed in the agency's forthcoming Autumn 2001 Sovereign Review (to be released later this week), the attack and possible international response have brought additional risks for the prospects for the global economy, which had, prior to September 11th, already deteriorated significantly:
- a major concern is that the terrorist attack could undermine US consumer confidence, which had already started to decline quite sharply. In the context of pressures on US household balance sheets - including from recent declines in equity prices - and rising job losses, this could see the US economy enter a more severe and prolonged downturn than currently expected;
- the other major risk to the global economy is from a sustained increase in oil prices due to increased tensions in the Middle East. This would reduce incomes in the major industrial countries and in some major emerging markets, though a number - including Russia (Long-term foreign currency rating, B) and Venezuela (BB-) - would benefit;
- emerging markets with heavy international financing requirements could also be adversely affected by any lasting increase in global investor risk aversion as a consequence of the event and its aftermath. Major emerging market borrowers could experience restricted access to market financing and increased funding costs. Latin America would be the most exposed, reflecting the region's still heavy external borrowing requirements and low national saving rates. By contrast, emerging Europe benefits from modest external borrowing requirements and from being higher up the credit scale.
At this stage it is simply too early to make any meaningful quantitative estimates of these risks. But Fitch does not expect adverse global economic and financial conditions to result in a rapid deterioration in creditworthiness in the major emerging market sovereigns. Many large emerging market borrowers - including Brazil (BB-) and Mexico (BB+) - have either pre-financed public sector external borrowing requirements for the rest of the year or have pre-arranged contingency plans. Nevertheless, even before last week's events, Fitch had placed Brazil's sovereign ratings on Negative Outlook due to its vulnerability to a further deterioration in the external environment, especially Argentina, as well as domestic economic and political concerns.
Argentina and Turkey
Argentina (B-) and Turkey (B) are the two most financially fragile of the major emerging market economies. In the case of Argentina, international capital markets were not open to it even before last week's terrorist attack on the US. Moreover, under current public financing plans, the Argentine authorities do not anticipate borrowing from international markets until late next year. The Turkish authorities had, however, planned as much as USD1.4bn foreign borrowing during the remainder of this year. This was always an overly ambitious target and not a key element of the government's financing plan. Of more concern is the effect of the heightened political and security risks on domestic
investor sentiment and willingness to at least partially rollover maturing domestic debt, while the reduction in the current account deficit will be hindered by higher oil prices and a fall in tourism. There have been suggestions that given Turkey's strategic location and membership of NATO, it is now more likely to receive additional international financial support if required. However, Fitch cautions that such assessments are at this stage highly speculative, but it does expect agreement on the deferment of repayments due next year under the IMF's Supplemental Reserve Facility, reducing debt payments to the IMF substantially below the scheduled total of USD5.5bn.
Emerging Asia
In Asia, dramatic improvements in external balance sheets in recent years and strong external liquidity positions leave countries relatively well placed to withstand a near-term deterioration in export revenues. For example, in Korea (BBB+), Malaysia (BBB), Thailand (BBB-) and the Philippines (BB+), foreign exchange reserves comfortably exceed short-term external debt. Nevertheless, Malaysia's credit outlook was changed from Positive to Stable last week, due to concerns over the effect of the US slowdown and the policy response of the domestic authorities. Were the US to enter a period of sustained economic weakness late into 2002 and beyond, consequences for the Asia could be much more severe, resulting in deteriorating credit quality across the region. Ongoing fragilities in corporate and banking sectors could prevent domestic demand from maintaining growth in the face of an export slump. Deteriorating credit quality across the private sector would likely require further fiscal support for banking systems, with adverse implications for public finances. Under these circumstances local currency sovereign ratings could come under pressure.
Middle East
The region's proximity to what appears the most likely focus of any military activity is likely to amplify negative investor sentiment and risk aversion. This will be especially so for those requiring access to international capital markets. Lebanon (B+) has increasingly resorted to financing large fiscal and current account deficits by borrowing in international capital markets. The combination of twin deficits, rapidly rising public debt and a pegged exchange rate regime leaves it vulnerable to external and domestic shocks, though Lebanon's dedicated investor base amongst domestic banks and the Lebanese Diaspora helps to contain its vulnerability to contagion and deteriorating risk appetite amongst international investors. Several countries in the region face major political challenges as their leaders balance international anti-terrorism commitments with potential domestic opposition to US-led military actions. Plans for economic and structural reform may, in the short-term, take a back seat. While Israel (A-) is very well-placed to absorb the economic and financial shocks that reverberate from last week's terrorist attacks and the potential fallout from the subsequent US-led response, Fitch remains concerned that a further deterioration in the political and security situation in Israel would, over time, undermine Israel's credit standing (placed in Negative Watch in May 2001). As regards any increase in oil prices, Kuwait (A+) would benefit most of rated sovereigns in the region while Lebanon and Israel are large net oil importers. Finally, declines in tourism receipts - significant for Egypt (BBB-), Lebanon, Tunisia (BBB) and Turkey - will have clear negative balance of payments implications, at least through the short term. In the presence of these new risks and their potential rating implications, Fitch will continue to monitor global economic developments very closely.
CONTACTS: David Riley, Brian Coulton, James McCormack, Richard Fox London +44 (0) 20 7417 4227 Shelly Shetty New York + 212 908 0324 End
-SS-