Bangkok--Nov 26--Fitch Ratings (Thailand)
Fitch-London-26 November 2001: Fitch, the international rating agency, has today downgraded Japan's Long-term local and foreign currency sovereign ratings to 'AA' from 'AA+'. The ratings remain on Negative Outlook. Japan's Short-term foreign currency rating is unchanged at 'F1+'.
Japan's credit fundamentals continue to deteriorate. The world recession has robbed the economy of its only bright spots in recent years i.e. exports and high-tech investment. In so doing it has uncovered a stagnant domestic economy, with the private sector still weighed down by balance sheet problems and a fragile financial system suffering from deteriorating asset quality. In a largely vain attempt to kick-start the economy, the government has continued to borrow roughly 8% of GDP per year. This has seen gross government debt rise above 140% of GDP and Fitch expects it to exceed 150% by end 2002. Fitch estimates that a fiscal adjustment of around 8% of GDP would be required just to stabilise the debt ratio at this high level. And this is without taking account of the need for public support for the banks or other contingent liabilities stemming from public sector enterprises, credit guarantees to small and medium-sized enterprises and the government's Fiscal Investment and Loan Programme.
Meanwhile deflation is taking a firmer grip. Prices have been falling for three years now and with the output gap widening sharply, deflation is expected to intensify to around 2?% next year. This would leave nominal GDP in 2002 smaller than in 1993, underlining the severity of Japan's "lost decade". By raising real interest rates, deflation will also exacerbate debt burdens in both the private and public sector. There is now precious little scope for using interest rate policy or quantitative monetary easing to combat deflation, but a sharp weakening of the yen would help.
With the economy on the brink of a recession worse than 1998, policy choices have become stark. Prime Minister Koizumi seems unflinching in his resolve to press ahead with privatisation, deregulation and limiting fiscal spending, even if this creates significant hardship in the near term. But he is meeting very considerable resistance from other members of the political establishment, mainly from within his own party, the LDP. Fitch recognises the serious efforts of the current administration in designing a wide-ranging platform for structural and public sector reforms, but notes that, at this stage, these plans remain lacking in the areas of financial restructuring and medium-term fiscal consolidation. The immediate future will be painful whatever policies are pursued and could even be aggravated for a time by reform measures. But quickly proceeding with the full range of reforms will be crucial for the Japanese economy to return to sustainable growth. However, implementing these policies is proving extremely challenging, as evidenced by the resistance to the planned consolidation and privatisation of the public highway corporations, an area where progress would be a positive sign. Fitch warns that continued denial over the severity of the economic problems facing Japan and persevering with a "muddling through" approach will over time further erode creditworthiness and Japan's sovereign ratings.
Japan's status as the world's largest net external creditor - with net external assets of around USD1.3trn - and its continuing capacity to generate excess savings largely insulates it from the risks of external crisis. This also allows the government to finance large deficits with relative ease and supports Japan's sovereign ratings. It also means that a "muddle through" choice by policy makers - involving continued fiscal stimulus, ongoing forbearance to the banks and gradualist reform - would probably not run into any major hurdles in the next few years. But it would pave the way for highly adverse medium to long-term public debt dynamics. For example, on the basis of no major change in policies and a continuation of recent historical GDP growth and real interest rates, government debt would be rapidly approaching 200% of GDP by 2007.
Fitch will be hosting a conference call to explain these rating actions on Tuesday 27 November at 14.00 GMT, further details to follow. A sovereign comment, entitled "Between a rock and a hard place: Japan's financial challenge" will be made available at www.fitchratings.com.
Contact: Brian Coulton, Bangkok Tel: +662 655 4755/4763
+ 44 (0)7946 854227
Lionel Price, London 20 7417 4206
Brett Hemsley (Banks) 20 7417 3494
Reiko Toritani (Banks, Tokyo) 81 3 3288 2673
David Marshall (Banks, Hong Kong) 85 2 2263 9911 End.
-AN-