RATINGS AFFIRMED FOR THAI BANKS THOUGH VULNERABLE TO DOWNSIDE RISKS

ข่าวทั่วไป Friday August 3, 2001 10:53 —PRESS RELEASE LOCAL

Bangkok--Aug 3---Fitch Ratings (Thailand)
Fitch-London/Bangkok-3 August 2001: Fitch, the international rating agency, has affirmed the Long-term ratings of six major Thai banks - Bank of Asia, Bangkok Bank, Krung Thai Bank, Thai Farmers Bank, Siam Commercial Bank, Thai Military Bank - with a Stable Outlook; their Individual ratings have also been affirmed or changed, as shown in the listing at the end of this release. DBS Thai Danu Bank's Individual rating is also affirmed.
The affirmations are a result of Fitch's annual review. It follows the banks' release of preliminary half-year results in July with signs of a faltering recovery in profitability, though, at this stage, not of such magnitude to warrant downgrades. Moreover, Thailand's sovereign rating, currently 'BBB-' (BBB minus) with a Stable Outlook, underpins the Long-term ratings of BB+ for the largest four Thai banks, BBL, KTB, TFB and SCB, as we expect government support to be forthcoming if needed. The sovereign also caps BOA's Long-term rating. Hence any revision of the sovereign rating would affect these banks' ratings.
While progress in debt workouts and restoring profitability has slowed during the past nine months, most of the Thai banks have come a long way from the depths of the crisis during 1997-1999, making substantial progress in recapitalising, provisioning, debt workouts and operational improvements. Nevertheless, the Thai banks still remain vulnerable to a severe downturn in the Thai economy. Official 2001 GDP forecasts have recently been cut to between 2%-3%, with the possibility of further downward revisions. This may expose vulnerabilities. Fitch takes note that while the ratings for the major Thai banks are affirmed, there are worrying signs emerging for the sector such as significant increases in relapse of restructured loans, new non-performing loans and declining net interest margins due to competition and prolonged weak loan growth.
On Fitch's analysis DTDB's and TFB's marginally higher Individual (or financial strength) ratings reflect their relatively conservative and pro-active approach in provisioning, capital raising, debt workouts and bad asset disposal, which should enable both to report more stable performances amidst a deteriorating environment. We also think BBL has a relatively high level of reserve coverage which should also enable it to report a more stable performance. However, government policies, such as the general guarantee for depositors and creditors and the Thai Asset Management Corporation (TAMC), appear to continue to support weaker institutions to the detriment of the stronger institutions. The raising of state-owned KTB's Individual rating reflects the transfer of bad loans to a separate government-owned asset management company in September 2000 and the proposed additional transfer of all the remaining bad loans to the TAMC in the second half of 2001. Although, its stand-alone position remains weak and its profitability poor.
POOR PROFITABILITY OUTLOOK IN 2001
Regulatory pressure to maintain or increase deposit rates from existing levels, together with competitive pressures to reduce lending rates, is placing further pressure on the banks underlying profitability. As a result, instead of last year's projected improvement to 2.5%, the agency expects net interest margins, on average, to decline to about 1.5% by end-2001. Non-interest income is improving in a difficult environment, though most banks reported losses on bond holdings in the second quarter, following confusion over the central bank's monetary policy. Several of the banks continue to make provisions, with the notable exception of Bank of Ayudhya (BAY). In the half year to June 2001, BAY remarkably reversed provisions against what, in Fitch's opinion, is already a very low level of reserves. BAY's Long-term rating was lowered to 'B+' with a Negative Outlook in August 2000, and Fitch will undertake its annual review of the bank in the coming month.
Two banks stood out for further large provisioning in the first half of 2001, BOA and KTB, with increases of THB3.6bln (USD80mln) and THB10.5bln (USD230mln) respectively. Fitch expects several other Thai banks will also need to make further provisions, resulting in net losses again this year for the Thai banks. DTDB is the only exception, having a relatively clean balance sheet. Several of the Thai banks still appear to be significantly under-reserved and vulnerable to further large provisions, particularly BAY and, to a lesser extent, TMB and SCB. Assuming continued regulatory forbearance, recognition of these losses is likely to be deferred over the next two to three years, allowing the banks to continue to operate, but resulting in prolonged poor net profitability.
TAMC - ESTABLISHED BUT ONLY MARGINAL BENEFIT
In a comment issued in March on the proposed establishment of the TAMC, Fitch said that while the state-owned banks would transfer the bulk of the bad loans, private banks were also likely to transfer about THB 250 bln (USD 5.5 bln) or about half their remaining bad loans. The agency thought the TAMC would mainly "benefit the weaker banks with lower levels of provisioning such as BAY, TMB, SCB and BOA" by relieving pressure on them to raise capital at least for a time. It now appears that it will offer only limited benefit even to the weaker private banks, as only about THB 100 bln (USD 2.2 bln) of bad loans, (less than one quarter of the private banks' remaining bad loans) will be sold to the TAMC. In some cases, the loans may also have to be revalued lower in line with valuations of the Land Department, which will require further provisioning before the transfer, (not at current provisions as initially proposed). Nonetheless, the banks should be able to absorb these losses. The validity of the TAMC may be challenged in court, which could weaken some of its key provisions. Assuming these uncertainties are resolved, the TAMC may still prove effective in assisting in corporate restructuring. Fitch estimates that once the bad loans are sold to the TAMC and with further progress in debt restructuring, NPLs should decline to about 15% of total loans by year-end. A broader economic recovery and corporate restructuring will be required to restore health to the Thai banking system. The high level of foreign investment inflows that are still required to recapitalise both the Thai financial and corporate sectors, combined with Thailand's still weak bankruptcy and foreclosure laws, accounting standards and regulatory forbearance, suggests rehabilitation will take several more years.
BANKS AFFECTED BY TODAY'S RATING ACTION
Bangkok Bank (BBL) Long-term 'BB+' Stable Outlook; Individual 'D/E'
Krung Thai Bank (KTB) Long-term 'BB+' Stable Outlook; Individual raised to 'D/E' from 'E'
Thai Farmers Bank (TFB) Long-term 'BB+' Stable Outlook; Individual 'D'
Siam Commercial Bank (SCB) Long-term 'BB+' Stable Outlook; Individual 'D/E'
Thai Military Bank (TMB) Long-term 'BB-' (BB minus) Stable Outlook; Individual 'D/E'
Bank of Asia (BOA) Long-term 'BBB-' (BBB minus) Stable Outlook; Individual 'D/E'
DBS Thai Danu Bank (DTDB) Individual 'D'
Contact: Dusadee Srishevachart; Vincent Milton, Bangkok Tel: +662 655 4762/4759
David Marshall, Hong Kong +852 2973 6293
Note to Editors: Fitch's Individual Ratings for Banks Fitch's Individual ratings assess how a bank would be viewed if it were entirely independent and could not rely on external support. This rating is not a debt rating but rather an assessment of the intrinsic strength of a bank. End
-AN-

แท็ก Bangkok Bank   thailand   central   nation   GDP   TOT  

เว็บไซต์นี้มีการใช้งานคุกกี้ ศึกษารายละเอียดเพิ่มเติมได้ที่ นโยบายความเป็นส่วนตัว และ ข้อตกลงการใช้บริการ รับทราบ