Bangkok--Jun 23--Fitch Ratings
Fitch Ratings, the international rating agency, today upgraded Bank of Ayudhya's ("BAY") Long-term foreign currency rating to 'BB-' (BB minus) from 'B+' and revised the Outlook to Stable from Positive. At the same time, the agency also took the following rating actions on BAY:
-- changed Support rating to '3' from '4';
-- assigned foreign currency subordinated debt rating of 'B+';
-- assigned a National Long-term rating of 'BBB+(tha)';
-- assigned a National Short-term rating of 'F2(tha)';
-- assigned a National subordinated debt rating of 'BBB(tha)';
-- affirmed the foreign currency Short-term rating at 'B';
-- affirmed the Individual rating at 'D/E'.
The change in the Support rating reflects the agency's reassessment of BAY's long-term market position, franchise and importance, which is considerable, as evidenced by its 9% market share for loans and 8% for deposits. This systemic importance should provide for a moderate probability of government support for BAY, if necessary. The upgrade in the Long-term ratings is based on the higher Support rating. BAY's Individual rating takes into account a partial recovery in earnings and margins, although profitability will likely continue to be affected by provisioning. However, the Long-term and Individual ratings are still constrained by the still-high level of impaired and restructured loans, as well as low reserve coverage and the need for further capital raising.
Fitch expects BAY's earnings and net interest margins to continue improving in 2004 following the redemption of hybrids in 1Q04 and a pick-up in loan growth, although competitive pressures and the bad debt overhang will continue to be a drag on profitability. Net loan loss reserves (LLR) at end-March 2004 totalled THB23.8 billion or still only 35.4% of impaired loans. Fitch notes BAY's LLR coverage appears significantly lower than other Thai banks, underlining the risks of further heavy provisioning.
While improving, BAY's very high net impaired loans-to-equity ratio of 145.1% underscores its balance sheet weakness. Nonetheless, improving collateral values, the expected earnings recovery over the next two-to-three years as well as the exercise of warrants by its shareholders, should assist in the restoration of BAY's balance sheet strength.
Meanwhile, Fitch has concurrently assigned Thai Military Bank ("TMB"), the other mid-sized commercial bank in Thailand, a foreign currency subordinated debt rating of 'B+', a National Long-term rating of 'BBB+(tha)', a Short-term rating of 'F2(tha)' and a 'BBB(tha)' subordinated debt rating. The agency has also affirmed TMB's Long-term and Short-term foreign currency ratings of 'BB-' (BB minus) and 'B' respectively, and Individual rating of 'D/E'. The Long-term rating Outlook is Positive. The affirmation of TMB's ratings comes as the bank finalises its acquisition of DBS Thai Danu Bank ("DTDB") and the Industrial Finance Corporation of Thailand ("IFCT"). Fitch says these ratings reflect TMB's still-weak but improving capital, reserve, impaired loans, earnings and profitability outlook. Fitch cautions however that asset quality weakness, particularly with the acquisition of a weaker entity like IFCT, still poses provisioning risks.
TMB's financial position has improved over the past year helped by a recapitalisation and the sale of bad loans. The tender offer for TMB's acquisition of DTDB and IFCT will be completed by end-June and the merger, including the transfer of all assets and liabilities of DTDB and IFCT to TMB, is expected to be concluded by end-September 2004. The merger will create Thailand's fifth-largest bank, with total assets of THB679bn. DBS is expected to provide technical support to TMB in several key areas. Nonetheless, TMB's financial position may be weakened initially by IFCT's weak operating performance, poor asset quality and low reserve coverage, although the merger should produce cost and business synergies in the medium-term, particularly with the support of a strong strategic partner in DBS Bank.
Note to Editors: Fitch's Support and Individual Ratings for Banks: Fitch's Individual ratings assess how a bank would be viewed if it were entirely independent and could not rely on external support. Its Support ratings deal with the question of whether a bank would receive support from its owners or from the state if it were to get into difficulty. These ratings are not debt ratings but rather, respectively, an assessment of the intrinsic strength of a bank and of any level of outside support that may, or may not, be available to it.
Note to Editors: Fitch's National ratings provide a relative measure of creditworthiness for rated entities in countries with relatively low international sovereign ratings and where there is demand for such ratings. The best risk within a country is rated 'AAA' and other credits are rated only relative to this risk. National ratings are designed for use mainly by local investors in local markets and are signified by the addition of an identifier for the country concerned, such as 'AAA(tha)' for National ratings in Thailand. Specific letter grades are not therefore internationally comparable.
Contact: Chaiyapat Paitoon, Vincent Milton, Bangkok
+662 655 4762/4759; David Marshall, Hong Kong +852 2263 9963. End.
-NT-